Ga naar inhoud

Wat wij vertelden aan de Parlementaire Assemblee van de Raad van Europa (PACE)

Logo van Parlementaire Assemblee van de Raad van Europa (PACE)

Begin november kwamen twee rapporteurs voor mensenrechten en democratie van de Parlementaire Assemblee van de Raad van Europa (PACE) naar Den Haag. Onze Tim Vos-Goedhart hield daar tijdens een rondetafelgesprek dit betoog:

Honourable Rapporteurs,

Thank you for inviting me to this roundtable.

I would like to discuss how digitalisation affects five core principles of the democratic rule of law: legality, democracy, fundamental rights, checks and balances, and judicial review.

I speak as a representative of the Open State Foundation, we are a non-profit and non-governmental organization. We position ourselves as both rebel and partner, which means we both exercise scrutiny of our government and simultaneously work with governmental organizations.

Government tasks and responsibilities in the Netherlands have grown in number and complexity. Public administration increasingly relies on algorithmic systems to carry out those tasks. The growing use of AI to support policy development and decision-making adds a new dimension to this dependence.

From the perspective of open government, this connects several of today’s topics. Parliamentary scrutiny depends on access to information. Journalists need evidence to investigate. Preventing corruption requires visibility over public decisions and private interests. And effective judicial protection requires that citizens can challenge the basis of decisions affecting them.

I want to highlight three concerns.

My first concern is the shift toward algorithmic and AI support in government at all levels and in all aspects of its functioning. Important public choices are increasingly made as choices in software design. Which data is checked, how categories and exceptions are defined and what is considered a ‘red flag’ that warrants further investigation.

Debating and examining legislation is therefore only a limited safeguard for fundamental rights. Democratic oversight and public scrutiny is needed on the translation from legislation into systems as well.

This requires transparency. Yet the Dutch government has stated that a legal requirement to publish information about the algorithms and AI in use is not deemed expedient at this time. This has stalled further work on adequate publication of the necessary information as can be seen in recent research. The latest report from the State Audit Service (ADR) found that the necessary information for proper checks and balances is still not provided in 32% of the cases researched. The explanation about the algorithmic system in use was often not clear or easy to follow.

When the government uses algorithms and AI, transparency should also cover the rules and instructions that guide algorithms including prompts and guardrails that are used in AI systems. These should be recorded alongside relevant inputs, outputs and the way organisations use those outputs. We need the role of AI in public policy making and decisionmaking to be traceable and explainable. A final decision or policy paper may tell us very little about the data, assumptions and system settings that shaped it. Public disclosure should be the norm, with exceptions justified by privacy or other legitimate interests in accordance with transparency laws.

My second concern addresses the access of information for journalists, citizens and watchdog organisations. Governments have never been inherently transparent. Where this sometimes led to conflict, often it was accepted. Society has however changed, we do not accept a closed off attitude anymore, transparency and openness are expected. This change does not appear to happen effectively in the Netherlands. It is common practice to skirt the edges of transparency laws and at times break them outright. This is most clearly illustrated by the missed deadlines when responding to information requests. But instead of fixing the underlying problem the Dutch government intends to limit the access to information by taking measures to address the problem of ‘overly broad requests’.

My last concern I want to share today is the delay of implementing a working and effective registration system to open up lobby. Research has shown that members of cabinet have often not been forthcoming with information about who they meet and what topics they discuss during those meetings. Without transparency about these contacts, the public cannot assess who has access to decision-makers or how private interests influence public decisions. Combined with hesitance in opening up UBO-registries this offers the perfect opportunity for corruption to take place out of sight.

With all three concerns, the same principle applies: the rule of law must be abided by in the broadest sense.. I ask you to make effective transparency a central recommendation of your review, so that our checks and balances are effective and the general public including journalists can exercise their fundamental rights, i.e. access to information, and have their rights protected such as right to a remedy and prohibition of discrimination.

Tim Vos-Goedhart

Blijf op de hoogte

Meld je net als 1600+ andere lezers aan voor onze maandelijkse nieuwsbrief!
Wat kan je verwachten? Zie onze eerdere nieuwsbrieven.